If you work in leadership development, you already know the landscape has shifted. The leaders you support are navigating constant change, rising uncertainty and complexity that would have felt unthinkable six years ago.
At GP Strategies, we’ve been researching what distinguishes the most effective leaders since 2019. The finding that keeps resurfacing is deceptively simple: the biggest leadership differentiator isn’t a skillset. It’s a mindset.
But our latest research, drawing on hundreds of leaders across industries, revealed something unexpected. Leaders overwhelmingly recognise the mindsets that matter: growth, inclusive, agile and enterprise. Yet they’re not struggling with understanding. They’re struggling with fear.
The fear no one talks about
This is not the kind of fear that makes headlines. This is subtler and more persistent. It’s often unspoken and rarely acknowledged in development programmes. But it’s powerfully shaping how leaders behave day to day.
Each mindset carries its own ‘fear signature’. Fear of being wrong holds back growth, while fear of failing publicly constrains agility and fear of social or political misstep makes inclusive leadership feel risky. And fear of sacrificing personal or team success pulls leaders away from enterprise thinking.
Today’s leadership landscape amplifies all of these. Work happens under closer scrutiny, with fewer layers of support and constant pressure to perform. Leaders aren’t rejecting these mindsets. They’re pulling back from the boldest expressions of them.
That pullback shows up consistently in practice. In workshops, I often see leaders nod at these mindsets, then pause when asked what they’ll do differently on Monday.
The need for practised courage
Fear and forward motion, it turns out, aren’t mutually exclusive. Beneath that pause often sits something L&D professionals should pay close attention to: a quiet form of courage.
Leaders are absorbing anxiety so their teams don’t have to. This duality (fear and courage coexisting) is one of the most important insights from our research.
That reframe changes the brief for L&D entirely. If fear is the real barrier, programmes that only build knowledge of these mindsets will fall short. Leaders need organisational permission and practised courage to act on what they already understand.
Leaders are absorbing anxiety so their teams don’t have to
Growth mindset: The foundation that unlocks everything
Growth emerged as the top priority: 46 per cent of respondents ranked it the most critical mindset. Without it, agility becomes reckless, inclusion becomes performative and enterprise thinking stays theoretical.
But while leaders value continuous improvement in principle, there’s a significant gap in risk-taking behaviour. They feel the weight of expectation. They’re supposed to have the right answers. The barriers are often structural rather than personal. Leaders lack environments that make growth safe.
Inclusive mindset: From empathy to courage
Leaders feel confident demonstrating the more visible aspects of inclusion, like seeking diverse opinions and creating opportunities to leverage differences. Where confidence drops is in the harder, more courageous dimensions.
Unlike other mindsets, inclusive leadership doesn’t have one clear obstacle to overcome. The barriers are multiple, interrelated, and context‑dependent.
Everything feels like a potential misstep, resulting in leadership hesitation. Not because leaders don’t care, but because they’re acutely aware of how their words might be misinterpreted.
The barriers are often structural rather than personal
Agile mindset: Rebalancing control and trust
Leaders agree agility is essential, yet many feel constrained by legacy systems, hierarchical approval chains and cultures that punish failure.
Modern agility demands more than adapting quickly. It requires a fundamental shift in how leaders use control: shortening decision cycles, empowering teams to act without constant sign-off and treating feedback as a strategic asset.
But moving without certainty triggers a fear of visible failure, and without systems that reward experimentation, even agile-minded leaders revert to caution.
Enterprise mindset: The first casualty of pressure
Leaders now recognise that an enterprise mindset (making decisions that serve the whole organisation) is essential. Those who embody it share resources, signpost risks early, and make decisions with the broader system in mind.
But under pressure, even well-intentioned leaders narrow their focus. This regression is rarely selfish. It is, more typically, unspoken anxiety. When leaders don’t feel safe acknowledging that anxiety, they revert to protective behaviours.
What this means for L&D
If you’re designing leadership development now, this research suggests several things worth sitting with.
Mindset work isn’t soft work. These mindsets are observable, measurable and directly connected to effectiveness.
And the barriers are often systemic, not individual. L&D has a role in advocating for the conditions – psychological safety, trust, distributed authority – that make courageous leadership possible.
Here’s what our research suggests for each mindset in practice:
Growth:
Normalise learning in public. Build programmes that encourage leaders to share mistakes as part of the curriculum. Create structured reflection cycles (after-action reviews, learning logs, retrospectives) that help leaders extract learning rather than rushing to fix.
Inclusive:
Help leaders learn to hold discomfort constructively. Empathetic questioning, slow-thinking strategies and curiosity-led dialogue help leaders stay present during tough moments. Frame inclusion as a performance driver, not a political minefield.
Agile:
Teach decision making under uncertainty through rapid experimentation, hypothesis-based planning and minimal viable action.
Train leaders in delegation and distributed authority. Agility grows when leaders trust others to act.
Enterprise:
Use cross-functional cohort-based programmes that build shared identity. Business simulations requiring enterprise-level trade-offs give leaders a safe space to practise before the stakes are real.
The leaders who thrive are not fearless. They are courageous. Development that builds deliberate courage, rather than treating mindsets as abstract concepts, will have a far greater impact.
What’s holding leaders back?
This article draws on findings from our report, Great Leaders Think Differently: The Four Mindsets Shaping the Future of Work, which includes detailed analysis, success indicators and practical guidance for leadership development.
Download the full report to discover what’s holding leaders back and what success really looks like in today’s transformed leadership landscape.
Your next read: What if it’s not a skills gap? Six things to try before a training fix
